Saturday, 10/31/26
In 2025, the Brookline City Charter Campaign sought signatures from 15% of registered voters. That is 6,169 of 41,121 registered voters at that time. State law requires 15 percent for what the campaign hoped would happen. It hoped a question would be on the May 5, 2026 ballot asking voters if they want the Town to form a Charter Commission to explore alternative structures of Brookline’s government, including transitioning from a town to a city. Norfolk County has 5 cities and 23 towns, Brookline being the largest town.
Upon certification review and subsequent challenging, Brookline City Charter campaign fell 314 signatures short, obtaining 14 percent of registered voters. To be clear, that 14 percent is not the percent of the Town who support the formation of a commission; it’s just the percent of registered voters who signed the petition.
I doubt the expressed interest of 14 percent of registered voters in Brookline has vanished. In light of this, I wondered what structures are there to consider? I mostly share what I learned from research; then I share an idea I had using imagination.
Structures
There are 5 primary structural types.
1. Council-Manager.
- About 55% of US cities.
- Voters elect a council to serve as the legislature, set policy, and pass ordinances. The council appoints a trained, professional city manager to handle administrative operations, execute policy, and manage municipal departments.
- The mayor is typically a member of the council (either directly elected or chosen by fellow council members) and usually presides over meetings, serving a largely ceremonial role or sharing policy leadership rather than executive command.
2. Mayor-Council
- Frequently used by larger US cities.
- Separates executive and legislative powers. Voters elect a mayor and a separate city council.
- Strong or weak mayor. Strong: mayor may prepare the budget, veto council legislation, and appoint or remove department heads. Weak: shares power and administrative duties with the council, often with a limited veto and less control over department appointments.
3. Commission
- Old, now rare (less than 1% of cities)
- Voters elect commissioners (usually 3 to 7)
- They act as the legislative council to pass laws and set policy, while each heads a municipal department and acts as an executive administrator.
4. Town Meeting
- a form of direct democracy found in New England states (like MA and VT)
- Eligible voters gather together and act as the legislature—voting on local laws, budgets, and tax rates.
- Daily executive duties are handled by an elected select board, at times working with a town manager.
5. Representative Town Meeting
- Outgrowth of Town Meeting, for larger towns where all voters cannot assemble.
- Voters elect many citizens (often ranging 100 to 300) to act as representatives at legislative meetings.
- Representatives debate and vote on town budget and bylaws, while executive power rests with a select board and/or an administrator.
…..
When Brookline was established in 1705, the structure was Town Meeting. In 1915, Brookline became the first town in Massachusetts to adopt the Representative Town Meeting, which we still have. In MA, a town must divide itself into voting precincts if its population exceeds 6,200 (M.G.L. Chapter 54 Section 6).
…..
Idea for an Alternative Structure
Before researching, I entertained the following alternative structure: Brookline could be a city with a bicameral legislature and a smaller Town Meeting (likely renamed, perhaps the Muddy River Meeting, but for purposes here I will continue to call it Town Meeting), keep the town administrator, and add a mayor.
If done, Town Meeting would be reduced from 255 members (15 members/precinct x 17 precincts) to 85 (15 members/precinct x 17 precincts). The Select Board would be part of the legislature, acting as the upper-body. It would hire and could fire the administrator and vote with Town Meeting, which Select Board has done with ‘at large members.’ The Town Clerk, Moderator, and state representatives living in Brookline would also still vote at-large.
The executive branch would include a mayor, town administrator, and the departments. The town would elect the mayor. The mayor would provide vision and political leadership with the administrator providing professional administration. There would be term limits. Impeachment of the mayor could happen by a majority vote in the Town Meeting minus the at-large members. The at-large members could try the impeachment. It would require two-thirds vote to convict and remove the mayor from office.
.....
Is the Alternative Structure Realistic?
This alternative structure sounded good to me, then I researched. What about the reduced number of Town Meeting members? According to Citizen’s Guide to Town Meetings from the MA Secretary of the Commonwealth and the MA Municipal Association, representative town meetings can total as few as 45 members, and typical ranges start around 50. So, 85 members would work. Some residents may cherish the history of town meeting; this structure keeps it. The Select Board would act as it has done, and having moved to the legislative branch, the position of mayor would ensure that the executive branch has elected leadership.
What is a major challenge to the alternative structure besides not fitting a model? I learned if a city in MA structures itself after standard city charters in M.G.L. Chapter 43 (City Charters), it cannot have a bicameral legislature. The legislative body of a city government is strictly defined as a single, unicameral body. That said, the Home Rule Amendment (Article 89 of the Amendments to the MA Constitution) says cities can draft unique, customized local charters, but the state legislature retains ultimate authority over structural boundaries.
Then I realized, that’s what the Charter Commission has the ability to do: design the structure of Brookline’s government. It’s done locally and voted on by residents without needing approval from the state legislature. If Brookline considers transforming from a town to city, I see where some may prefer the Council-Manager structure, perhaps more so than other structures, partly due to Brookline’s size, and that would eliminate the historic Town Meeting. On the other hand, the alternative structure that I have entertained keeps that while separating powers of the legislative and executive branches.

Copyright © 2026 Rogers Brookline - All Rights Reserved.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.